Philosophy & Reflections

No Word for Light Blue – By Ailbíona McLochlainn

March 25, 2022

The English language lacks a dedicated word to describe the colour light-blue. In the same manner, for instance, that  ‘light-red’ is called pink, and ‘light-purple’ is lilac, there is no blue equivalent. Other languages treat light-blue as a concept in its own right. In Ukrainian the colour is called блакитний {blakitnyi} which translates approximately as ’sky’ – approximately, because the structure of the language transforms the word into an adjective form.

Inanely, I find my mind fixating on these linguistic details when I see the colours of the Ukrainian flag posted on social media in signs of solidarity. So much of the flag’s iconography relates to that specific shade of sky blue. Being unable to name it in English, to evoke it and all that it represents with a single distinct word, feels like an erasure of something, a closed door to an ‘other’ cultural space.

Though I was born in what is present-day Ukraine, I am not Ukrainian. It is complicated. The region is complicated. The history is complicated. The nationalities, ethnicities, and boundaries are complicated. And it is all about to become more complicated, as the current conflict and its fallout produce more trauma, more displacement, more dissociation. It is not my intent to talk about the politics of it here, or to curate sympathies toward this conflict while neglecting harrowing events elsewhere in the world. But I want to talk about seeing – and not seeing.

What is it that we see, when we look at cultures that are inherently ‘other’? Can we ever get past the obvious iconography, past the stereotyped imagery?  Or do these things function as a highly effective veil, keeping us from the substance that defines this other cultural space? When it comes to former-Soviet cultures, the iconography can be so strong it is almost perceived as caricature-like. Which, in turn, can have dehumanising effects.

In Ukrainian, blakitnyi is not just about the existence of a single word to describe a pastel colour. The idea of light-blue, or sky-ish, is afforded a great deal of cultural and artistic space. And it is the inability to cross over to that space, to that sky-ish frame of mind as it were, that creates a schism. Is it possible to support that which we don’t understand? Or in doing so, are we merely supporting our own projections?  It may not matter in the immediate sense, when support is badly needed in very concrete terms. But it matters, I feel, in the long-run.

And then there is the question of displacement. When the richness of a cultural tapestry that one has proverbially always stood, sat, and slept on, is pulled out from underneath, what is left but a schism?

In the past I have struggled at being perceived as a diasporic artist. Billing me in that manner and interpreting my work through that lens, was unnecessary, I thought, and reductive. It was only later in life, having gained exposure to the work of many contemporary artists, writers, and photographers with migratory pasts, that I  acknowledged the similarities. And it is less about the subject-matter than it is about the feeling of the work. A certain sense of claustrophobia to the imagery. A desperation. A hopelessness. A failed struggle for control over one’s surroundings. ‘There is a certain recognisable brand of chaos to the work of post-Soviet artists,’  a college professor once said to me, and it sent me into a spiral of self-doubt. It is not easy to accept that one’s creative energies can be reduced to that.

There is no word for light-blue in English, and neither are there words for certain thoughts and emotion I’d like to succinctly share, but can’t. I have stopped feeling frustrated by this, and have tried instead to express these things through craft and photography. In the series I am currently working on  I have started to combine the two: The tableaux style photos utilise garments I’ve made over the years, to pose questions about trauma, performance, and memory.

If this missive seems vague and abstract, my apologies – and I do acknowledge it is both of these things. Admittedly I myself did not know where I was going with this piece and how I would relate it to photography. But I think the relationship is implicit, and so perhaps it is best after all that I give readers the opportunity to formulate their own thoughts on the subject – using this stream-of-consciousness piece as a trajectory.

___

NOTES

Header Image:
4 panels from the ongoing series Jadwiga {I am in the leftmost photo}. All images taken with a Leica CL and a Summicron-C 90mm lens. The dress was hand-knitted using Donegal tweed and designed based on a combination of Eastern European decorative motifs.

Second Image:
from the ongoing series Flora. Taken with a Leica CL and a Summarit 75mm f2.4 lens. The top was hand-knitted using Swedish heritage-breed wool, designed based on the turn of the 20th century sailor aesthetic.

Ailbíona McLochlainn is a photographer, knitwear designer, and recovering academic, based in Ireland. For additional information and lots of pictures to look at, visit www.ailbiona.com

 

Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience

There are two ways to experience 35mmc without the adverts:

Paid Subscription - £2.99 per month and you’ll never see an advert again! (Free 3-day trial)
Subscribe here

Content contributor - become a part of the world’s biggest film and alternative photography community blog. All our Contributors have an ad-free experience for life.
Sign up here.

14 Comments

  • Reply
    John
    March 25, 2022 at 10:43 am

    The word you seek is “azure”, used in English to denote the pale-blue colour of a cloudless sky.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 25, 2022 at 10:53 am

      The equivalent of azure also exists, but it’s a separate colour from this one.

      Moreover, I would say the likes of azure and cerulean are used predominantly in a painterly/ artistic context; you would not use them colloquially as you would for instance pink… Colloquially you would say light-blue. But you would not say light-red, even though technically, pink is indeed light red. It’s a linguistic difference that IMO has interesting cultural implications.

  • Reply
    theo vervloet
    March 25, 2022 at 10:59 am

    LOOK AT THIS WEBURL https://www.canva.com/colors/color-meanings/pastel-blue/

    PASTEL BLUE IS THE COLOUR ORIGINALLY OF VEGETABLE PLANT PASTEL THAT GAVE AN ENTIRE INDUSTRY IN SOUTH OF FRANVE IN THE REGION TOULOUSE ALBI. THE PASTEL PLANT HAD YELLOW FLOWERS WA TREATED AND GAVE SURPRISINGLY A BLUE COLOUR THAT WAS DILUTED IN ALL BLUE TINTS. THE MOST USED WAS BLUE PROVENçAL AND WAS IMPOSED BY THE ADMINISTRATION FOR DOORS, WINDOW BLINDS, AND A LOT OF MORE. THANKS FOR YOUR POST. THE PASTEL PLANT BLUE WAS REPLACED BY THE IMPORT OF OVERSEAS BLUE AND INDIGO. THRE IS A REVIVAL NOW VERY ACTIVE.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 25, 2022 at 12:38 pm

      Wow. I have a very busy work schedule today and absolutely did not need to be looking up articles on the pastel revival, but it is fascinating – thank you!

  • Reply
    Thorsten
    March 25, 2022 at 11:15 am

    In German we have “hellblau” light blue. Often is is used for bluish cyan tones. On the ohter hand we the at greenish cyan tones, lake green ” Seegrün”. Often they are called “türkis” dependent the stone. It is more bluish.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 26, 2022 at 11:06 am

      I speak German, though not very often these days. Seegrün and hellblau have such evocative effects on me, somehow very different than ‘sea green’ or ‘light blue’ in English, even though they mean the exact same thing.

  • Reply
    Terry B
    March 25, 2022 at 11:51 am

    If I’ve understood you correctly блакитний (blakitnyi) refers to the specific hue of the blue in the flag of Ukraine. If so, then there must be other Ukrainian words to describe other hues of blue, surely? As there are only three primary colours, red, blue and yellow, from which all other colours can be generated, it follows that mankind needed a means to express the myriad of hues that would be created, and be more prescriptive. Taking hues from nature is an obvious example, and in English, if you ask anyone to name hues of blue, specifically in the region of “light blue”, how many would come up with cornflower or periwinkle and which have been used to assist those to understand a certain hue of blue?

    Other naming principles relate to a specific hue, such as Prussian blue, or Royal blue, or one in the UK “pillar box red” with most knowing what this is. Although a google search seams to favour branded hair dyes over the real thing!!

    I love that very colourful knitted jumper, although I’m not of the right gender to pull it off.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 26, 2022 at 11:09 am

      It’s a floor-length dress actually… and I bet you could totally pull it off.

  • Reply
    Lee
    March 25, 2022 at 12:33 pm

    As someone who is rather severely colorblind, I think it’s interesting to read about or listen to people with normal color vision debate the specifics of subtle hues. I have a strange relationship with color, for me there are only 4 variations on any color, blue for example: Blue, Dark Blue, Light Blue, or I have no clue what color it is.

    And in order for me to come close to determining what basic color something is, there needs to be enough of the color to stand out from whatever is around it. I have learned over the years that I it’s just not worth it for me to get too engaged in a color discussion. The best way I can come up with to describe being colorblind is that I just don’t have the word association with color and I have no confidence in my own ability to discern colors. I see colors, but I don’t really know what many of them are.

    As you might imagine, this can pose a challenge photographically. I just see the world differently and I have absolutely no idea what I’m missing out on, but it’s probably a lot. So you can keep your “cerulean”, your “azure”, your “lilac”, your “cobalt”. I’ll just call it blue and hope that I am right.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      April 3, 2022 at 11:13 am

      Ooh, sorry – I somehow missed your comment earlier.

      My grandfather could not differentiate between blue and green. I discovered this as a child when he was helping me with a mosaic puzzle type of thing. Mentioned it to my mother, and she had no idea. I do not think most people around him realised. He knew how to deduce the correct colour most of the time, based on context, just as you say. It didn’t get in the way of his serving in WWII, or working in the textile industry later on, which is interesting.

      Out of curiosity, do you mostly shoot in black and white? And if you do shoot in colour, do others ever notice anything unusual about your photos?

  • Reply
    Bud Sisti
    March 25, 2022 at 5:08 pm

    Beyond the specific discussion of color names (or the lack of them), your piece raises the crucial question of how we engage with “otherness”. My feeling and experience lead me to believe that we should acknowledge that other individuals and cultures are in some ways opaque to us, and may never be fully understood. And that’s OK; I try to live with the difference, and celebrate it, even as it may prove disorienting or puzzling to me. The worst thing, I believe, is to insist that we’re “all basically the same”, an attempt to erase what we don’t understand about “the other”. But I think we are hard-wired to avoid those gray areas, of course, and it requires a conscious effort to live in them and accept the unknown, the “other”, as in part unknowable, without fearing it.
    By the way, I do so love your description of yourself as a “recovering academic”! May I borrow it for my own use?

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 25, 2022 at 7:46 pm

      The otherness was the idea I was trying to express, with the musings on colour as a trajectory. It always fascinates me how the aspects of a piece I consider least significant often tend to generate the most interest. (That’s not a criticism of those commenting on the colour thing! More like a self-criticism of my not anticipating what will resonate with an audience.)

      Ha feel free to use ‘recovering academic’… Alas there are no support meetings for the likes of us!

  • Reply
    Michael J
    March 26, 2022 at 10:12 am

    The thing of colours as fundamentally adjectival is very “other” to a native English speaker like me, and very interesting- I have to actively turn them into adjectives! The Polish ‘atramentowy’ for dark blue is both a favourite word and colour, from my very sketchy studies of that language.

    • Reply
      Ailbíona McLochlainn
      March 26, 2022 at 11:03 am

      Ooh you broke my brain (in a good way) with ‘fundamentally adjectival’!
      Must go off and think about that now.

Leave a Reply

This site uses User Verification plugin to reduce spam. See how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience -Click here to find out more
+